Sunday, February 16, 2014

Week 6 On a Second Thought...



On a second thought, after weighing the pros and cons before my dilemma to whether re-start my final project or continue what I have begun, I believe in continuing.

The refining of the final project for a course I will probably teach next term is in progress as follows:

The problem to solve, I had mentioned the week before last week, is that only pictures from magazines are available at Pre- Advanced students' disposal for picture analysis practice in class and outside class in my teaching setting.

What I plan to do in order to help my class solve that problem is the use of Google Images as an image search engine. I think it will be useful in resolving the issue because I can take my students to our computer lab when I plan to make them practice "picture analysis", and let them search for topic- based photos to be downloaded for later use. This lab session should logically go with my topic- based "picture analysis" lesson plan (including Pre-, While-, and Post- activities). This alternative will take the place of  old magazine picture use for students' practice in class that my teaching colleagues and I are used to.

This sixth week, I want to give more details about the lesson plan mentioned above.
To start with, every time I plan to have students practice picture analysis, a Pre- activity would be to discuss in class what topic/ situation the class is interested in this session. Once the topic is defined, students can go online using Google Images and search for pictures related to that topic. The question that remains unanswered is how my students will be able to analyze a picture if they are not taught/ trained to do so; the reply to that big question is: each session of picture analysis always comes with a skilled- based mini lesson, which helps students reach their goal. For example, if one session's focus is on accuracy for learning the basics of how to speculate on past/ present/ future events, students can go to  http://www.slideshare.net/eoi.soraya/modals-of-speculation  and http://english4all.pro.br/LEpastmodals.htm before getting photos to analyze at http://www.google.com/imghp . Other possibilities to introduce picture analysis to students, at the beginning of this classroom/ computer lab project are the resort to http://www.cyberbee.com/quicklessons/photo.html; http://english-tonight.com/8-ways-you-can-use-pictures-to-speak-better-english/ and http://efllecturer.blogspot.com/2011/09/describing-photos-comparing-contrasting.html . For students to be familiar with sentence- connectors, they are advised to go to https://elt.oup.com/student/solutions1stedition/ui_unit_page/unit7/grammar/exercise2?cc=us&selLanguage=en and (especially) http://www.eslbee.com/transitions_and_connectors.htm .
When students gradually feel comfortable analyzing pictures through those steps, the kind of follow-up activities they can have is like using this rubric, for them to measure themselves what efforts have been made and will be made:

This is how SS' work will be evaluated:


Worth 5 points
Worth 3 points
Worth 1.5 points
TOTAL SCORE/ 35 points
What the chosen photo shows
 setting + people + activity  (3 elements)
(2/3 elements)
People or setting only

What are described in audio
People and their feeling, place, time, activity (5 elements)
(3/ 5 elements)
Only 2 elements
How listener follows the narrative
Coherent and logical
Logical, but not coherent
No logic; no coherence
What are/ is speculated on
Possible past, present and future events (3 elements)
2/ 3 elements
Only one element
Vocabulary content
Extensive
Enough
Insufficient
Linking words
Frequently used
Fairly used
Scarcely used
Oral delivery
Very fluent and clear
Clear, but not fluent
Hardly understood

That is all I can give as far as this project is concerned.

Thanks for reading and commenting on it.

4 comments:

  1. Hi Manda,
    I have read your lesson plan with a great interest, since I am working on the same topic "describing photos" in the Webquest. My web quest is being designed for Pre-Intermediate level young adults.The links you have shared here can be useful for my students ,too. Especially http://english-tonight.com/8-ways-you-can-use-pictures-to-speak-better-english/ seems appealing and useful,since I want my students listen to authentic materials. I assume, it will be interesting for students to evaluate the speakers using the given rubric. It will help them to make their own descriptions better.

    Best,

    Samarat

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Samarat,

      Thanks for being interested in my lesson, which is also my final action plan. I am glad to hear that one of my suggested sites may be useful for others.

      As I have mentioned in your blog of Week 6, I want to do the peer- project review with someone who has something in common with me. You may be that person unless you want to work with someone else.

      Thanks in advance!

      Manda

      Delete
  2. Dear Manda and Samarat,

    Your topic seems interesting and full of thought provoking ideas. I also like the idea of sharing the rubric on the blog to be clear for your peer Manda.

    Wish you all best

    Ouarda

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks a lot, Ouarda! Good luck in your project.

      Manda

      Delete